
Division M starts tonight, which means we are 75% of the way through the Round of 512. And 37.5% of the way through the whole tournament. Votes are due by Wednesday at 10 pm. Janos is taking back over for M and N, but I’ll see y’all for O and P. Grooveshark link is here, except for Let It Be. I had a tough time finding a decent version of LIB on youtube, so if you have your own I’d say use that.
**** (Folks, Janos here. I see I’m late for at least 8 voters, so it’s a lost cause, but for all folks who were staggered by the album version of Such a Night, take a look at this, and maybe you’ll feel better about it)
Oh yeah, and don’t forget to check Bracketology for updates on the Road to the Sweet Sixteen. All the brackets thru Division K are up and live.
I Fought The Law (Clash) vs. Welcome To The Jungle (Guns N Roses)
Is This Love (Bob Marley) vs. Such A Night (Dr. John)
Kashmir (Led Zeppelin) vs. Tiny Dancer (Elton John)
Rock & Roll Music (Chuck Berry) vs. My Girl (Temptations)
Sloop John B (Beach Boys) vs. Let It Be (Beatles)
I Fought The Law (Clash) 7.5
Welcome To The Jungle (Guns N Roses) 6.5
Is This Love (Bob Marley) 7.5
What A Night (Dr. John) 2 [how some if these songs get into the tourney of best song of all time is fucking baffling to me.]
Kashmir (Led Zeppelin) 5.5
WRONG SONG- this is the orchestral instrumental.
Here’s Zepplin: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sfR_HWMzgyc
Tiny Dancer (Elton John) 8
Rock & Roll Music (Chuck Berry) 4
My Girl (Temptations) 6
Sloop John B (Beach Boys) 7
Let It Be (Beatles) 8.5
I Fought The Law (Clash) 4
Welcome To The Jungle (Guns N Roses) 6.5
Is This Love (Bob Marley) 4 [My roommate yelled at me about listening to this]
What A Night (Dr. John) 3
Kashmir (Led Zeppelin) 4.5 [Goddamn is this song STILL going on?]
Tiny Dancer (Elton John) 7
Rock & Roll Music (Chuck Berry) 5.5
My Girl (Temptations) 5
Sloop John B (Beach Boys) 6.5
Let It Be (Beatles) 8.5
…I did not have very strong feelings about this bracket.
I Fought The Law (Clash) 6
Welcome To The Jungle (Guns N Roses) 8
Is This Love (Bob Marley) 5
What A Night (Dr. John) 4
Kashmir (Led Zeppelin) 7
Tiny Dancer (Elton John) 9
Rock & Roll Music (Chuck Berry) 6
My Girl (Temptations) 7.5
Sloop John B (Beach Boys) 6.5
Let It Be (Beatles) 8.5
I Fought The Law (Clash) 6
Welcome To The Jungle (Guns N Roses) 7
Neither is really a morning song. I may revise these votes later when the coffee’s kicked in.
Is This Love (Bob Marley) 8.5
What A Night (Dr. John) 5
Kashmir (Led Zeppelin) 7.5
Tiny Dancer (Elton John) 8
Close one, both really nice instrumentals, Zeppelin just was a little over the top while Elton nailed it the whole way through.
Rock & Roll Music (Chuck Berry) 7
My Girl (Temptations) 7.5
Both a bit dated, but My Girl’s sweet sappiness trumps Rock & Roll’s cheese.
Sloop John B (Beach Boys) 7
Let It Be (Beatles) 8.5
Kudos to the Beach Boys for keeping the Beatles hungry and honest, but the brits are just alot better…
I Fought The Law 8
Welcome To The Jungle 7
Tough call. Feeling I Fought The Law a bit more- probably because I just went to the DMV this morning and as expected, left frustrated and chagrined with the universal ineptitude of motor vehicle agencies.
Is This Love 8.5
Such A Night 3
This is my Marley. Nothing complicated, just good old fashioned chill and good. If this Dr. John song is the Zydeco representative, this is a mistake. Even sweet memories of Jazzfest aren’t gonna save this one.
Kashmir 6
Tiny Dancer 9.5
I never appreciated Kashmir, maybe that’s a mistake…it’s just so f-ing long. Tiny Dancer, wow…so I got some flak from a voter for my S&G America score last week, on the basis of “how can you give it that score? haven’t you ever seen Almost Famous?” And I sorta felt sad about that, because I love Almost Famous, but for Tiny Dancer more than any other Golden God, S&G, anything else moment. Seriously though- everything in life becomes good when I hear Tiny Dancer.
Rock & Roll Music 5
My Girl 6
Thought My Girl would get a better score- is Motown running out of steam at this point? As the Parisian street punks would say, oof.
Sloop John B 7.5
Let It Be 9
The story of Sloop John B is a little cool, and has a pretty good associated Wikipedia article. The story of Let It Be just blew my mind out of the water of this coffee shop. During the making of The White Album, when the Beatles were fighting a lot, Paul McCartney had a dream one night. His mother, who passed away when he was 14, came to him and said: “It will be all right, Paul. Just let it be.” And that gave him the inspiration to write this song. Oof^2.
Actually, on two more listens, change Let It Be to a 10. I needed this one today.
I Fought The Law (Clash) 6 vs. Welcome To The Jungle (Guns N Roses) 9
Is This Love (Bob Marley) 7 vs. Such A Night (Dr. John) 5
Kashmir (Led Zeppelin) 7 vs. Tiny Dancer (Elton John) 7
Rock & Roll Music (Chuck Berry) 6 vs. My Girl (Temptations)8
Sloop John B (Beach Boys) 8 vs. Let It Be (Beatles) 7
Fought The Law 8
Welcome To The Jungle 6
Reading judicial decisions on corporate law all day (good god how my life has fallen off in the last week…) makes the law worth fighting here too. Not in a GnR mood these day – maybe hearing 2 minutes of Chinese Democracy has ruined them for my ears…
Is This Love 8
Such A Night 2
How can you not love Marley? No clue what’s up with Such a Night – lowest average score of the tournament coming here?
Kashmir 6
Tiny Dancer 6
Kashmir’s first 4 minutes are like an 8… but damn that just went on and on… wonder what they were on at the time. Tiny dancer has highs (beginning and end) but a sort of soft middle to me. All in all, not really possessed of a strong opinion either way.
Rock & Roll Music 4
My Girl 6.5
Sloop John B 7
Let It Be 5.5
I Fought The Law (Clash) [7]
Welcome To The Jungle (Guns N Roses) [6]
Is This Love (Bob Marley) [7]
Such A Night (Dr. John) [5]
Kashmir (Led Zeppelin) [6]
Tiny Dancer (Elton John) [8.5]
Rock & Roll Music (Chuck Berry) [6]
My Girl (Temptations) [8]
Sloop John B (Beach Boys) [7]
Let It Be (Beatles) [9]
I Fought The Law (Clash) 7.5
Welcome To The Jungle (Guns N Roses) 8
Is This Love (Bob Marley) 8.5
Such A Night (Dr. John) (correct version) 7.5
Kashmir (Led Zeppelin) 6.5
Tiny Dancer (Elton John) 9.5
Rock & Roll Music (Chuck Berry) 7
My Girl (Temptations) 8.5
Sloop John B (Beach Boys) 8.5
Let It Be (Beatles) 8
I Fought The Law (Clash) 9 vs. Welcome To The Jungle (Guns N Roses) 9
Is This Love (Bob Marley) 6.5 vs. Such A Night (Dr. John) 3
Kashmir (Led Zeppelin) 7 vs. Tiny Dancer (Elton John) 8.5
Rock & Roll Music (Chuck Berry) 9 vs. My Girl (Temptations) 7
Sloop John B (Beach Boys) 8 vs. Let It Be (Beatles) 9.5
I Fought the Law (Clash) – 5
Welcome to the Jungle (Guns N Roses) – 4.5
Is This Love (Bob Marley) – 6
What A Night (Dr. John) – 7
Kashmir (Led Zeppelin) – 4
Tiny Dancer (Elton John) – 9.5
Rock & Roll Music (Chuck Berry) – 7
My Girl (Temptations) – 6
Sloop John B (Beach Boys) – 8
Let It Be (Beatles) – 10