Other than Beatles vs. Stones, these match-ups weren’t really close. Paul Heintz was devastated watching Loving Cup go down only days after Man in the Mirror.
Norwegian Wood (Beatles) def. Loving Cup (Rolling Stones), 81-79.
Paranoid (Black Sabboth) def. Violet (Hole), 91-66.
Criminal (Fiona Apple) def. Borderline (Madonna), 87-71.
Mysterious Ways (U2) def. Bhindi Bhagee (Joe Strummer), 91-71.
You Took the Words Out of My Mouth (Meatloaf) def. First We Take Manhattan (Leonard Cohen), 74-60.
Living the Dream 
Meatloaf over Leonard Cohen (esp on that song) is a travesty.